Assessment Tools for Successful Library Evaluations

A Practical Guide

Holt Zaugg
Emerald
Emerald

This book can be opened with

Glassboxx eBooks and audiobooks can be opened on phones, tablets, iOS and Android devices

Hardback
9781836627555
01 June 2026
£80.00
eBook (PDF)
9781836627548
11 May 2026
£80.00
eBook (ePub)
9781836627562
11 May 2026
£80.00

Note on our eBooks and Audiobooks: you can read our eBooks (ePUB or PDF) and listen to audiobooks on the free Emerald Books app on iOS, Android, and desktop. Or read and listen on Emerald's online reader (ePUB eBooks and audiobooks only). To purchase a digital book you will need to create an account if you don’t already have one. After purchasing you will receive instructions on how to get started.

  • Description
  • Contents
  • Reviews
  • About

Assessment Tools for Successful Library Evaluations is an essential guide for professionals involved in evaluating library operations or teaching assessment methods. Contributions offer clear, detailed descriptions of key assessment and evaluation techniques, complemented by practical examples that demonstrate how these principles can be applied and adapted to any library setting.

Various performance measurement tools are evaluated, such as ethnographic techniques, focus groups, interviews, observations, surveys, and usability testing. Chapters provide examples of how librarians have used these methods, along with guidance on applying each method to assess different aspects of library operations. This helps describe the library’s value and supports data-driven decision-making for strategic improvements. Examples of each assessment method are drawn from different types of libraries worldwide, including academic, public, school, government, and medical libraries.

This is a valuable resource for library managers and assessment librarians across all sectors. For those with assessment experience, it provides a quick refresher of the learning and skills related to library evaluation. For those teaching or learning about assessment as part of an MLS program, Assessment Tools for Successful Library Evaluations is a reference resource that will help instructors present methods and students to learn and apply the methods.

Introduction to First Section

  • Chapter 1. An Introduction to Focus Groups; Holt Zaugg
  • Chapter 2. An Introduction to Interviews; Holt Zaugg
  • Chapter 3. An Introduction to Observations and Ethnographies; Holt Zaugg
  • Chapter 4. An Introduction to Surveys; Holt Zaugg
  • Chapter 5. An Introduction to Usability Testing; Holt Zaugg
  • Chapter 6. An Introduction to Visual Assessment Methods; Holt Zaugg
  • Introduction to Examples Section
  • Chapter 7. Passing the Baton: An Interview Between Mentor and Student on Library Assessment and Evaluation; Colleen Cook and Kara Schleck
  • Chapter 8. Using Focus Groups for Library Assessment: Insights from Three Projects; Jung Mi Scoulas
  • Chapter 9. User-driven Design: Usability Testing to Improve an Academic Library’s Research Guide; Mercedes Rutherford-Patten
  • Chapter 10. Conversations that Count: Using Interviews for Library Assessment; Lizzie Cope
  • Chapter 11. Instructional Repositories: Building from the Ground Up; Jillian Speck
  • Chapter 12. Fostering Connections and Community Through Celebrating Virginia Tech's Therapy Dogs: A Series of Observation Studies; Esther Dowell and Kelsey Hammer
  • Chapter 13. Is This Really an Ethnography? Using “Ethnographish” Methods to Study Library Space; Kimberly Vardeman and Sarah D. DeVille-Holly
  • Chapter 14. Using Surveys to Evaluate Digital Literacy Competencies among Undergraduate Students in Nigerian University Libraries; Bolaji David Oladokun and Yusuf Ayodeji Ajani
  • Chapter 15. Survey-Driven Improvement in Academic Libraries: Methodology and Application in a Communication and Trust Study; Rebecca J. Peterson, Pamela R. Hallam, Lane Fischer, and Ross Larsen
  • Chapter 16. Joining Forces: Enhancing Website Usability Through UX and Assessment at an Academic Library; Josie Cotton and Liz Bober
  • Chapter 17. Evaluating Website Effectiveness Through Student-Centered Usability Testing; Lori L.Steckervetz, Olivia Rossetti, and Connie Strittmatter
  • Chapter 18. Small Changes, Big Impact: Improving Accessibility in Library Spaces Through Student Collaboration; Dan Herbert
  • Chapter 19. What’s Next?; Holt Zaugg

Assessment Tools for Successful Library Evaluations is an essential resource for practitioners, educators, and students seeking to develop or enhance their library assessment practices. Zaugg provides clear explanations of core assessment methods, including focus groups, interviews, surveys, usability testing, visual assessments, and more. Each methodological chapter is paired with practical case studies contributed by library assessment practitioners from around the world, which illustrate how these approaches are applied in real-world settings. This approachable resource helps librarians overcome common speed bumps in assessment and build confidence in data-driven decision-making.

- Rebecca A. Croxton, PhD, associate professor and strategic assessment librarian, Colorado State University Libraries

The book offers practical exposure to assessment and evaluation work and explains several techniques used in assessment, evaluation, and usability testing. It is a unique resource, the first of its kind, which provides comprehensive understanding of tools and techniques for successful library assessment. Numerous case studies enrich readers' understanding immensely. This valuable resource and reference guide equips students, information scientists, library professionals, researchers, faculty members, academic administrators, and policymakers with comprehensive insights into library assessment and usability testing, along with the nuances of evaluation tools and techniques. It is a must-read for library professionals working in all types of libraries who want to revamp their functioning

- Dr Raj Kumar Bhardwaj, St Stephen’s College, Delhi, India

Holt Zaugg is the Assessment Librarian at the Brigham Young University Library, Provo USA. He is responsible for the user experience, value description, and process improvement assessments of library services, spaces, resources, and personnel. Over the past 11 years, he coordinated or conducted over 120 assessments of academic library services, spaces, resources, and personnel interactions with patrons and library employees, resulting in multiple peer-reviewed publications as well as two dozen conference and workshop presentations.